The Douglas County Voucher Case: Colorado's Choice Scholarship From 2011 to the U.S. Supreme Court
By My Learning Source · November 21, 2026 · News, Scholarships, Guides
When people say Colorado "had a voucher once," they mean Douglas County. From 2011 to 2017, the Douglas County School District's Choice Scholarship Pilot Program went from a school board vote to the Colorado Supreme Court to the U.S. Supreme Court. Here is the story from the court records, as of October 31, 2026, and what it means for families who homeschool. Our Colorado homeschool options guide has the wider school choice picture.
How the program worked
The Colorado Supreme Court's 2015 opinion describes it. In 2011 the district created the Choice Scholarship Pilot Program, which awarded taxpayer-funded scholarships to qualifying elementary, middle and high school students to help pay tuition at partnering private schools, including religious schools. In the pilot phase, up to 500 Douglas County students were eligible.
The money ran through a public school that, in the trial court's words, "has no buildings, employs no teachers, requires no supplies or books, and has no curriculum": the Choice Scholarship Charter School. Scholarship students enrolled there on paper, the district counted them for state per-pupil funding, kept 25% for administration, and sent the other 75% to the chosen private school as a check made out to the parent and endorsed for tuition. For 2011–12, per-pupil revenue was estimated at $6,100, so the scholarship was $4,575, or less if tuition was lower.
At the time of the injunction hearing, 271 students had been accepted at 23 private school partners. The trial court found 16 of those 23 schools religious in character.
Round one: trial court and court of appeals
Douglas County taxpayers and others sued. The trial court found the program violated the Public School Finance Act and several provisions of the Colorado Constitution, and permanently enjoined it in 2011. The Colorado Court of Appeals reversed in 2013, holding that the challengers lacked standing under the finance act and that the program didn't violate the state constitution.
Round two: the Colorado Supreme Court, 2015
On June 29, 2015, in Taxpayers for Public Education v. Douglas County School District, 2015 CO 50, the Colorado Supreme Court ruled in two parts:
- The challengers lacked standing to sue under the school finance act.
- A plurality held that the program violated article IX, section 7 of the Colorado Constitution, titled "Aid to private schools, churches, sectarian purpose, forbidden."
The court sent the case back so the trial court could reinstate its permanent injunction. Chief Justice Rice announced the judgment. Justice Márquez concurred in the judgment. Justice Eid, joined by Justices Coats and Boatright, concurred in part and dissented in part. That split is why it's called a plurality: no single opinion on the constitutional question drew a majority of the court.
Round three: the U.S. Supreme Court, 2017
The district asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case. The Supreme Court's docket, No. 15-557, shows the petition filed October 28, 2015. On June 27, 2017, the Court granted the petition, vacated the Colorado judgment and sent the case back "for further consideration in light of Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. Comer," a religious-liberty case it had decided that month. The mandate issued July 31, 2017.
"Vacated" matters. It means the 2015 Colorado judgment no longer stands as the final word in this case.
How it ended
The case didn't end with a new ruling on the merits that we could find. The district's own policy library lists a December 4, 2017 certified board resolution to rescind the Choice Scholarship and School Choice Grant programs. We couldn't open that document, so we can't tell you its text or the vote. We also found no official court record of how the remanded case was closed, so we won't describe one. If you need the details, the district's board records and the courts are the places to ask.
What it means now
- Colorado has no voucher today, local or statewide. The Legislative Council Staff's January 2026 issue brief describes private schools and homeschools as non-public education that receives no public funding.
- The constitutional language at the center of the case, article IX, section 7, is still in the Colorado Constitution; the same brief cites it.
- Because the 2015 judgment was vacated and the program was rescinded, how Colorado courts would rule on a similar program today is an open question. We won't predict it.
- Amendment 80, the 2024 attempt to write a right to school choice into the constitution, failed. We cover that in a separate article.
Why homeschool families were never in it
The Choice Scholarship paid tuition at partnering private schools. A home-based education program in Colorado isn't a private school; C.R.S. 22-33-104.5 says it "does not qualify as a private and nonprofit school." So even at its height, the program had nothing for families teaching at home. The same is true today of every option labeled "choice" in Colorado: what homeschool families can use is part-time public classes and programs, activities, and concurrent enrollment arranged through a public school.
A Douglas County family's take
The Bergstroms moved to Castle Rock in 2013, while the scholarship was still tied up in court, and looked into it for their oldest. They've homeschooled since 2016. When a newer neighbor asked whether "that voucher" was coming back, Mom pulled up the court records and walked her through it: struck down in 2015 by a plurality, vacated in 2017, rescinded by the board. What their family uses now is a district class for their teen and a Saturday science club they pay for themselves.
(A composite example — names and details are illustrative, drawn from situations homeschool families commonly describe.)
Quick reference
- 2011: Douglas County starts the Choice Scholarship Pilot Program; the trial court permanently enjoins it.
- 2013: The Colorado Court of Appeals reverses.
- June 29, 2015: The Colorado Supreme Court reinstates the injunction (2015 CO 50, plurality on the constitutional question).
- June 27, 2017: The U.S. Supreme Court vacates and remands in light of Trinity Lutheran.
- December 4, 2017: The district's policy library lists a board resolution to rescind the program.
- Find tutors and curriculum in our vendor directory, local events on our education calendar, and other families in our community.
My Learning Source is an independent marketplace and is not affiliated with the Douglas County School District, the Colorado Judicial Branch, the Supreme Court of the United States or any party to this case. This is a summary of public court records, not legal advice — read the opinions and docket yourself before you rely on them. Family examples are composites, not real individuals.